I wasn’t hungry when I first saw that bag of pasta staring at me on the countertop, but the idea of cheesy, creamy comfort had other plans. Suddenly I had a boiled pot of noodles, chicken sizzling in garlic butter, and a mound of cheese whispering “come join us.” The kind of dish that fills your kitchen with irresistible scent and spoons out second helpings. One accidental splash of cream near my sleeve became a badge of bravery—I call it my cooking uniform. Those noodles? Perfectly al dente, not mush, with a golden sheen of garlic-infused butter that felt like a hug to the pan. I tossed chicken coated in spices—paprika, a pinch of cayenne—with a bit of salt and pepper. Steam rose, and I nearly inhaled the first sizzling moment too early… but it just meant I was invested. When I stirred the cream in, I thought “this might get too rich,” but once the cheese started melting, that worry dissolved fast. That first melty stretch, when cheese and pasta become one slippery, cozy bite—that’s when I knew I hit the mark. I may have licked the pasta spoon before it even cooled. Don’t judge me—it’s part of the cooking process. This recipe is so forgiving, dear friend. Seriously, if you only have half the cream, add milk and extra cheese—you’ll still land somewhere comforting. Overcooked chicken? Still tender in sauce. Want to bulk it with veggies? Just stir them in. I once tossed in leftover broccoli, and it felt like a jackpot. Saucy, cheesy, chicken-studded noodles that make day-old dishes feel glamorous again. My kitchen looked like pasta bombed it—splatter on the wall, cheese on the floor—but there’s something charming about those crumbs. Four hands grabbed forks before the plates made it to the table. Saucy fingers, happy hums, and that quiet moment when everyone sighs with full hearts. I’ll make this again tomorrow—probably with bacon or a splash of wine in the sauce, but fundamentally, this is pasta made right: easy, cheesy, and unapologetically comforting.
Detailed Ingredients with measures
- 8 oz pasta (penne, rotini, or your favorite)
- 2 boneless, skinless chicken breasts, diced
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 3 garlic cloves, minced
- ½ teaspoon paprika
- Pinch of cayenne pepper (optional)
- ½ teaspoon salt (more to taste)
- ¼ teaspoon pepper
- ½ cup heavy cream (or half-and-half)
- 1 cup shredded cheddar cheese
- ½ cup grated Parmesan cheese
- Optional: steamed broccoli, crispy bacon bits, or red pepper flakes
Prep Time
About 15 minutes—enough to chop, boil, and whisk your way toward cheesy bliss (and maybe wipe a rogue cheese strand or two).
Cook Time, Total Time, Yield
Cook Time: 10 minutes for pasta, 10 minutes for chicken and sauce—20 total. Total Time: About 35 minutes from kitchen chaos to “dinner done.” Yield: Serves about 4 hungry people—though if stories are true, that might shrink to 3.
Detailed Directions and Instructions
Season and cook the chicken
Begin by slicing chicken breast horizontally into thin strips. Coat them with olive oil and dried herbs, then season with salt and pepper. Heat a frying pan until it’s hot enough to sizzle—and proceed to give those strips a good sear, around four minutes each side until golden and just cooked through. Once done, set them aside to rest, because you want the juices to stay in the chicken, not all over the pan.
Boil the pasta and reserve water
Meanwhile, get some salted water boiling and cook your pasta until al dente. I always undercook by a minute because this dish keeps on cooking in the sauce. Scoop out a cup of that starchy pasta water before draining and set it aside—this is your secret to a saucy hug later.
Sauté diced vegetables
In the same pan you used for chicken, lower the heat and melt some butter along with a splash of oil from your sun-dried tomato jar—because flavor depth is never overrated. Add finely diced onion and carrot; let them soften and get just a hint of color. This is where the taste starts building.
Layer in garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, and thicken the sauce
Toss in minced garlic and chopped sun-dried tomatoes—watch them sizzle and breathe life into the pan. Sprinkle in flour, stir it through, and let it cook for a minute. Then pour milk and stir until the sauce starts to thicken. If it looks too coy, those saved pasta waters will coax it just right.
Pull it together with shredded chicken and cheese
Shred the rested chicken with a fork and stir it into the sauce along with grated cheese. Give everything a gentle mix, then add a splash of the reserved pasta water if the sauce feels too thick. You want ribbon-like creaminess, not stickiness.
Finish with pasta and serve hot
Toss in your cooked pasta and give it a few folds until every spiral is coated. Serve immediately with a sprinkle of Parmesan and fresh herbs if you’ve got them. One forkful, and you’re immediately happy—even if your shirt’s a little speckled with sauce.
Notes
Let the chicken rest
Skipping that rest makes your cooked strips dry. Give them a quick break, and your sauce stays juicy.
Save pasta water
That salty starchy water is like gold here—it turns a thick sauce into something smooth and drape-able.
Don’t rush the veg
Soften those onions and carrots slowly—they add sweetness beneath the cheesy layers.
Cheese choices are personal
Tasty cheese gives strong flavor; switch to Colby or Edam if that’s what’s in your fridge. You’ll still be smiling.
Reheat or freeze carefully
If reheating or freezing, stir in a little extra milk to loosen it back up. Nobody likes dried-out pasta memories.
Cook techniques
Grilling chicken that tries to go rogue
Oh boy, I once let my herby-coated chicken stay on the griddle a bit too long, and it insisted on sticking to the pan—complete with the gorgeous golden bits. Now I blast up the heat, watch like a hawk, and give those strips a little nudge with a spatula so they don’t cling for dear life. When it finally releases, that’s the sweet moment you want.
Juggling pasta water like a clumsy acrobat
Let’s be honest—saving that cup of starchy pasta water is like a game of memory and memory fails happen. One time I tossed it prematurely, leaving me scrambling with a gluey sauce. Now I stick it in a measuring cup beside the stove, glaring at it until it finds its way into the creamy goodness just when it starts to thicken. Crisis averted.
Sauteing veggies in a dance of butter and tomato oil
You know when the butter foams and you throw in onions and carrots hoping for gentle softening? Yeah, I’ve over-stepped that line. One batch turned more crispy than tender because I got distracted by my phone buzzing. Now I stir constantly, the pan moves back and forth like a slow dance, and I sniff-check for that sweet softness—no distractions allowed.
Stretching the sauce without turning it into paint
Adding cheese and shredded chicken to the sauce is pure pleasure until it acts like a stiff wall. That’s when you coax it with a tablespoon (or three) of pasta water. But be gentle—one too many splashes and it becomes soup. I’m still mastering that fine line between velvety coating and thin puddle, but hey, those imperfect batches still plate beautifully.
FAQ
How long can this dish hang out in the fridge?
I usually stash leftovers for up to three days in a snug, airtight container. On the second day, flavors have melded and if the sauce feels too clingy, I just warm it with a splash of milk or broth. It’s like reclaiming its once-was glory.
My sauce is stubbornly thick—help?
Thick sauce dilemma? I’ve been there. Just sneak in a bit of reserved pasta water—go slow, stir, assess, and repeat until it relaxes to a smoother coat over the pasta. Feel free to call it “rich and indulgent” if your guests ask about the texture.
Can I skip the sun-dried tomatoes?
Totally. I once made this sans those tangy chunks—still good, but definitely missing that savory pop. Without them, maybe toss in a pinch of red pepper flakes or a squirt of lemon juice to bring some brightness back into the mix.
Is this dish freezable for future fridge raids?
Yup. I freeze by portioning into freezer-friendly containers (label them—trust me). When you thaw and reheat, warm it gently and swirl in a dash of milk to bring back the creaminess. Just don’t forget and try reheating frozen sauce like soup—major drainage moment.
Conclusion
I can’t help but giggle when I think back to the first time I tried making this cheesy chicken pasta—it was utter chaos. I forgot to reserve pasta water at all, which resulted in sauce that clung like wallpaper paste, and I may or may not have pulled that pan off the stove with a mitt that was halfway melted. But you know what? It was still so good, even a bit gluey was kind of charming (just don’t do that on purpose). Now I always grab the pasta water and keep my mitts far enough away that no part of me is at risk. This recipe hits comfort like nothing else. That herby chicken, sliced and grilled until golden, adds such flavor, and the veggies—onion, carrot, sun-dried tomatoes—are little flavor superheroes. Stirring them up in butter and a drop of that sun-dried tomato oil makes your kitchen smell like, well, like you should probably open a window—but also like Sunday dinners at Grandma’s house, minus the perfect tablecloth. When the cheese melts into that creamy, flour-thickened sauce and you toss it all with the spiral pasta, don’t be surprised if everyone’s suddenly hovering, plate in hand, at your elbow, asking “Is it ready yet?” Even the person who swore they never liked chicken pasta sneaks back for seconds—no judgment, I do too. I promise you’ll be scraping that pan afterward, making mental notes: “Next time, double it.” And let me confess: despite the ambitious plan, I rarely remember to double it—but hey, I always end up eating every bite, so that’s something. Honestly, the charm lies in those little flubs I make along the way. When I shred the chicken with two forks, it flies everywhere—counters, floor, you name it. Sauce spatters turn into “art,” and the burnt-on bits at the bottom of the pan become unofficial flavor boosters. And that moment when you thin the sauce with a splash of reserved pasta water? Instant silk. So if your kitchen ends up looking like it survived a food fight, you nailed it. That slightly messy, totally real vibe is exactly what turns a weeknight supper into something that feels like a warm hug from an old friend.
More recipes suggestions and combination
One Pot Macaroni, Chicken and Peas
Because sometimes you want minimal dishes and maximum comfort—dip into creamy pasta with chicken and hidden peas, all in one pot.
Chicken Pesto Pasta Bake
Swap out the creamy sauce for pesto love, toss in spinach, bake until golden and bubbly—trust me, it’s a tasty switch-up that saves brain energy.
Creamy Tomato Chicken Pasta Shells
For a brighter, tangier spin—think tomato sauce, baby spinach, and melting mozzarella wrapped around big pasta shells. Feels lighter but still doesn’t skimp on indulgence.
Chicken Fettuccine
Pan-fried chicken, onion, garlic, and that silky cream sauce pulled together with parmesan—you’ll see your spiral pasta recipe nodding in respectful applause.
Creamy Fettuccine with Chicken Bites
Crispy, spice-rubbed chicken pieces perched atop garlic-cream coated fettuccine, with parsley tossed in for that “I totally meant to do that” freshness.
Chicken, Tomato and Asparagus Pasta
Fresh, bright, and feels like spring: penne, homemade tomato sauce, asparagus and peas, crowned with grilled chicken and crumbled feta—light but satisfying.
